Health Byte 005: How Wal-Mart's Primary Care Ambitions Crumbled
Wal-Mart's decision to stop operations of both its clinics and virtual care services signifies a notable reversal in its efforts to change how healthcare is delivered.
Decoding Health is broadening the understanding of what truly influences our health. If you haven’t subscribed, join our community of readers by subscribing here:
Alongside our newsletter, the Decoding Health podcast is available on leading platforms like Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.
How Wal-Mart's Primary Care Ambitions Crumbled
Wal-Mart, the retail giant known for its “everyday low prices”, had big plans to make healthcare more accessible and affordable by opening health centers where patients could see a doctor, get their prescriptions filled, and even have lab work done—all under one roof. With ninety percent of Americans living within 10 miles of a Walmart store and 4,000 of those stores located in HRSA-designated medically underserved areas, Wal-Mart had the potential to make a real difference in the health and well-being of communities in need.
Source: Wal-Mart and Yahoo Finance
But now, Wal-Mart is doing a complete 180. They're shutting down all 51 of their health centers and pulling the plug on their virtual care service. This comes as a big surprise, especially since they recently announced plans to open 28 new health centers this year. Despite this major setback in its primary care ambitions, Wal-Mart isn't abandoning healthcare completely, with plans to continue operating its nationwide network of pharmacies and vision centers.
Wal-Mart isn't the only one dialing back on their initial healthcare ambitions. Last month, Optum, a subsidiary of UnitedHealth Group, announced the closure of its virtual care business. Walgreens plans to shutter more than 160 VillageMD clinics as part of a strategic realignment.
So, while it might just seem like another business venture that didn't pan out, Wal-Mart's retreat feels like a missed opportunity. It's a letdown for the families who saw a glimmer of hope in those health centers—a chance at a healthier life that now feels further out of reach.
The big question is: what went wrong?
Misaligned Incentives with Payers
The costs of setting up and maintaining these clinics can be sky-high, and the reimbursements from insurance companies for basic healthcare services? Not so impressive. This is particularly true for primary care services, which are often considered a loss leader in the healthcare industry. In other words, clinics often lose money on these services. Many healthcare systems that invest in primary care do so with the expectation that it will lead to increased referrals to specialty care within their network, where margins are typically higher.
Despite its best efforts to make preventive care more accessible and affordable, Wal-Mart may have underestimated the uphill battle of getting reimbursed by national insurance carriers. When it comes down to it, if you want to shake things up in healthcare and try out new delivery models, you need health plans to be on board. And that's true no matter how big or powerful your company might be.
Rising Labor Costs and High Turnover Rates
Scaling healthcare facilities is an expensive endeavor, and the costs can quickly add up.
One of the biggest expenses? Staffing. With fewer and fewer doctors in the U.S. choosing to specialize in adult primary care (we're down to about 25% now), it's getting harder and harder for patients to get the preventative healthcare they need. That's a big problem because it means that roughly 100 million Americans don't have a primary care provider, all because there just aren't enough of them to meet the demand. The shortage has sparked intense competition among healthcare organizations, including retail-based clinics such as those operated by Wal-Mart, to get their hands on the limited number of primary care providers out there.
But it's not just about the money. Providers are also leaving the industry in droves, burnt out from long hours and the emotional toll of the job. This high turnover rate means that clinics are constantly struggling to maintain a stable workforce, further driving up costs and straining resources.
These staffing challenges have a direct impact on Wal-Mart's ability to deliver on its core value proposition: convenient, accessible care. With a limited number of providers and constant turnover, it becomes increasingly difficult to offer the kind of walk-in, on-demand care that customers expect from a retail clinic.
Cookie-Cutter Approach in a Crowded Market
Wal-Mart struggled to differentiate itself: their cookie-cutter clinics and telehealth services didn't bring anything truly unique to the table. They were, in essence, just another player in a sea of similar offerings.
Without a unique selling point, Wal-Mart's health services were left to compete on price and convenience alone. But here's the thing: in a market where everyone is offering similar services, price and convenience can only take you so far. Patients are looking for more than just a low-cost, accessible doctor's visit. They want quality care, and a healthcare experience that feels tailored to their needs.
The retail giant may have had the scale and resources to weather these challenges longer than most, but even Wal-Mart couldn't overcome the fundamental problem of operating in a saturated market. By failing to differentiate itself, Wal-Mart's clinics and telehealth services were left vulnerable to the same market pressures and financial challenges that have affected many of their competitors.
Key Takeaway
Wal-Mart's withdrawal from the primary care and telehealth space is not entirely surprising. The skills needed for selling groceries and household goods are significantly different from those essential for providing healthcare services.
Thank you for reading! Subscribe here to receive Decoding Health in your inbox:
In addition to our newsletter, you can find the Decoding Health podcast on major platforms such as Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.